Best Stores to Buy Soccer Jerseys in New York

Best Stores to Buy Soccer Jerseys in New York

Finding the perfect soccer jersey in New York City feels a lot like trying to find a quiet subway car during rush hour: impossible, but not completely hopeless.

Where to start, with all the options available?

The authentic match-day jersey, which matches the price of your monthly budget for coffee? Or a replica, which does an almost equal job, not making your wallet cry its eyes out in a corner?

Don’t worry; I’ve been there, done that, and bought the jersey, quite literally.

In this guide, we will break down the best places to buy soccer jerseys in New York City-from the obvious to the obscure.

This guide will walk you through the best places to buy soccer jerseys in the city that never sleeps.

Why New York is a Soccer Jersey Paradise

New York City is a melting pot of cultures, and soccer is not any different.

You’re going to get people of a very wide nature from everywhere around the world; thus, you’ll find virtually any fan base you might be looking for.

This variety flows into retail outlets, from which you will get jerseys for every team within the English Premier League, La Liga, Serie A, Bundesliga, MLS, and even any other national teams in the world.

Whether you’re looking for the latest Nike, Adidas, or Puma kits, retro throwbacks, or custom designs, NYC has something for everyone. Plus, the city’s vibrant soccer culture means you’re never far from a store that caters to your fandom.

Modell’s Sporting Goods

Best Stores to Buy Soccer Jerseys in New York

    Let’s start with a New York institution. Modell’s Sporting Goods has been a go-to destination for sports fans for over 130 years.

    While the chain has faced challenges in recent years, some locations still carry a solid selection of soccer jerseys. You’ll find popular teams like Manchester United, Barcelona, and the New York Red Bulls, as well as basic gear for local leagues.

    What to Expect:

    • Mainstream teams and leagues abound.
    • Seasonal sales and discounts especially during major tournaments like the World Cup or Euros.
    • A mix of authentic and replica jerseys. Be sure to check the labels if you have something particular in mind.

    Pro Tip: If you need to do a last-minute purchase, Modell’s is great for that. For more specific, anything niche, you may want to look somewhere else.

    Upper 90

    Best Stores to Buy Soccer Jerseys in New York

      If you love soccer, it’s time for you to visit Upper 90. This exclusively soccer shop found in Harlem and Brooklyn sells only soccer merchandise ranging from jerseys to cleats down to accessories or memorabilia that one might associate with the game.

      What to Expect:

      • Highly selected category of jerseys stemming from top flights and national leagues.
      • Extravagantly designed and most limited edition kit collections you simply can’t come across elsewhere in town.
      • Knowledgeable staff, just like you, enthusiastic about soccer.

      Pro Tip: If you want to add your name or unique design to your kit, take a look at their jersey customization services.

      Adidas Originals Store

      Best Stores to Buy Soccer Jerseys in New York

        Soccer and streetwear have become increasingly intertwined, and the Adidas Originals Store in SoHo is the perfect place to embrace this trend.

        While it’s not exclusively a soccer store, you’ll find a fantastic selection of Adidas-sponsored team jerseys, including iconic clubs like Real Madrid, Bayern Munich, and Arsenal.

        What to Expect:

        • Stylish, fashion-forward designs that blend soccer culture with urban aesthetics.
        • Collaborations with designers and artists, offering unique takes on classic kits.
        • A chance to snag exclusive releases and limited-edition items.

        Pro Tip: Even if you’re not buying a jersey, the Adidas Originals Store is worth a visit for its cool vibe and Instagram-worthy displays.

        Niky’s Sports

        Best Stores to Buy Soccer Jerseys in New York

          Tucked away in the Bronx, Niky’s Sports is a family-owned store that has served the local community for decades. Without the pizzazz of some other retailers, Niky’s is nonetheless a treasure trove for soccer fans.

          What to Expect:

          • Affordable prices on jerseys from a wide range of teams and leagues.
          • A focus on local and international teams, making this a great place to find jerseys from lesser-known clubs.
          • A no-frills, authentic shopping experience that feels like stepping back in time.

          Pro Tip: Don’t be afraid to ask the staff questions, as they are very knowledgeable and can help you find what you’re looking for.

          Soccer Garage

            The Soccer Garage is primarily an e-commerce website, but they do have a showroom in Manhattan where you can see their huge inventory. Due to their large stock and decent prices, Soccer Garage is a haven for serious fans.

            What to Expect:

            • One of the largest selections of soccer jerseys in the city, including many rare and hard-to-find kits.
            • Inventory is regularly updated so that the latest releases are always available.
            • The option of online shopping to order and fetch your goods is for added convenience.

            Pro Tip: Sign up with their newsletter for sales and new arrivals updates.

            CHECK OUT | Why Do Soccer Players Wear Shin Guards?

            Paragon Sports

            Best Stores to Buy Soccer Jerseys in New York

              Paragon Sports in Union Square is a high-end sporting goods store that, for all intents and purposes, provides just about anything anyone involved in sport could want, including soccer.

              While their selection may not be the largest out there compared to some specialized stores, they surely make up for it in quality and authenticity.

              What to Expect:

              • Quality selection of jerseys from top teams and leagues.
              • A focus on performance wear, so you’ll find jerseys designed for both fans and players.
              • A sleek, upscale shopping environment.

              Pro Tip: Paragon Sports is a great place to shop if you’re looking for a jersey to wear on the field, as they prioritize functionality and comfort.

              Local Soccer Shops

                Small soccer shops, often independent and reflecting the interests of a particular community, line New York City.

                The stores are very likely to stock jerseys from teams in Latin America, Africa, and other parts of the world that might not be represented in the bigger retailers.

                What to Expect:

                • A unique selection of jerseys reflecting the diverse culture of soccer in the city.
                • Affordable prices with the chance to support local businesses.
                • A more personal shopping experience, with owners who are often passionate soccer fans themselves.

                Pro Tip: Explore neighborhoods like Jackson Heights, Queens, or Washington Heights in Manhattan to discover these hidden gems.

                Stadium Goods

                  If you’re into both soccer and streetwear, Stadium Goods in SoHo is worth a visit.

                  While they’re best known for their sneaker collection, they also carry a selection of soccer jerseys that blend sport and style.

                  What to Expect:

                  • Selection of classic and new jerseys, with a lot of attention to style and fashion.
                  • High-quality, limited-run pieces for collectors.
                  • Upscale, hip shopping experience.

                  Pro Tip: Be prepared to shell out a little extra in this store. Stadium Goods truly houses all the premium products.

                  CHECK OUT | Do Soccer Goalies Wear Knee Pads? A Complete Guide

                  eBay and Facebook Marketplace

                    Whether in your budget or on a look at for older jersey versions, never underestimate places such as eBay or Facebook Marketplace; several of them around the NYC area post and resell at much more ‘friendly’ prices than retailers often sell their pieces for.

                    What to Expect:

                    • A huge scope, from the very rarest of any vintage kit releases down to recently dropped ones.
                    • Possible to haggle the price for some good deals.
                    • The convenience of shopping from home, with the option to meet sellers locally.

                    Pro Tip: Always check the seller’s ratings and reviews to ensure you’re getting an authentic product.

                    Pop-Up Shops and Events

                      New York City is known for its pop-up shops and events, and soccer is no exception.

                      During major tournaments or when big teams visit the city, you’ll often find temporary stores selling official merchandise.

                      What to Expect:

                      • Items and jerseys that you won’t find anywhere else but here.
                      • A fun, festive atmosphere, celebrating the global soccer community.
                      • The possibility of meeting other fans and sharing your passion for the game.

                      Pro Tip: Follow your favorite teams and leagues on social media to stay up-to-date with future pop-ups and events.

                      CHECK OUT | Is Soccer Good for Weight Loss? Yes, and Here’s Why

                      How to Buy Soccer Jerseys in NYC

                      Before you go on your jersey-buying spree, here are a few things to remember:

                      • Check for Authenticity: If you are buying from a non-official store, then the jersey should be authentic. Look for official logos, tags, and holograms.
                      • Know Your Size: Soccer jerseys tend to run tight, so if you prefer a looser fit, you may want to size up.
                      • Shop During Sales: Many stores run sales during the off-season or around major holidays. Keep an eye out for discounts.
                      • Explore Different Neighborhoods: Some of the best finds are in unexpected places. Don’t be afraid to venture outside Manhattan.
                      • Ask for Recommendations: If you’re unsure where to start, ask fellow fans or join a local soccer group for advice.